Modi earned the title 'Butcher of Gujarat' through his own actions: Bilawal Bhutto

Former Foreign Minister and Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari reiterated his strong criticism of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, stating that his use of terms like "butcher of Gujarat" or comparing Modi to Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu are not insults, but descriptions rooted in Modi’s own actions and policies.

In a recent interview with Al Jazeera, Bilawal was asked about the apparent contradiction between his harsh criticism of Modi and his calls for diplomatic engagement with India.

In response, he clarified that calling out human rights violations and advocating for dialogue are not contradictory positions.

“I don’t think it’s mutually exclusive to call out apartheid, violations of international law, or threats to starve civilian populations, and at the same time advocate for peace,” he said, while also alluding to Modi’s policies in Kashmir and his broader posture toward Pakistan.

Resolution of all issues with India lies through Kashmir: Bilawal Bhutto

When asked specifically about calling Modi the “Butcher of Gujarat,” Bilawal defended his choice of words, stating that this is a title earned by Modi himself due to his role in the 2002 Gujarat riots, during which hundreds of Muslims were killed.

 “It’s not a label I give him. It’s a title his own actions earned,” Bilawal said firmly. He added that his sharp critique was not personal, but a call for Modi to reflect on what kind of legacy he wants to leave behind.

Addressing the question of whether such strong language could hinder future peace talks, Bilawal responded that if Prime Minister Modi wishes to lead responsibly, he must be able to engage in dialogue, regardless of criticism.

Check: Bilawal warns India of grave consequences for using water as a weapon

“I believe the Indian prime minister has a thick enough skin to sit across the table from me anyone else,” he remarked.

He stated even when Modi made harsh statements, like saying Pakistani youth would have to choose between his bread or his bullet, Pakistan still showed readiness to engage diplomatically.

When asked about his praise for US President Donald Trump depsite his support for Israel’s actions in Gaza, Bilawal noted that he acknowledged Trump's constructive role in easing tensions between Pakistan and India's context, which is why he praised that specific aspect of his policy.