ICC criticized for 'double standards' after supporting Indian army but banning Usman Khawaja

The International Cricket Council (ICC) has come under intense global scrutiny after showcasing its double standard over solidarity after its chairman, Jay Shah, expressed public support for the Indian armed forces during escalating tensions between India and Pakistan, while previously banning Australian cricketer Usman Khawaja for promoting a peace symbol.

Shah, who was also the son of India’s Home Affairs Minister, posted a message on Instagram praising Indian military personnel following a terrorist attack in Pahalgam, Kashmir, that claimed the lives of 27 civilians.

India launched Operation Sindoor in response, blaming Pakistan-based militants. The situation has since spiralled into cross-border missile, drone, and artillery exchanges, prompting India to suspend the Indus Waters Treaty, further straining diplomatic ties.

In an instagram post Shah wrote: “Our armed forces are our pride and no words are enough to express their valour and commitment in protecting our motherland and people. We salute our brave men and women in the armed forces who are shielding our nation from terrorism.”

The post drew immediate criticism due to Shah's dual role as an Indian national and the head of cricket’s global governing body. Critics argued that his open political expression during an armed conflict contradicts the ICC’s enforcement of neutrality for players, citing the case of Usman Khawaja, who was banned from displaying a peace dove and human rights messages during the 2023 Boxing Day Test.

Veteran journalist Malcolm Conn condemned the apparent double standard, writing on X: “So, Usman Khawaja is banned by the ICC from putting a dove on his bat supporting peace in the Middle East, but ICC chairman Jay Shah can openly support the Indian military during conflict. Staggering hypocrisy!!!”

Khawaja, known for his advocacy of humanitarian issues, was ordered to cover slogans such as “Freedom is a human right” and “All lives are equal”, and was also reprimanded for wearing a black armband. His proposed dove symbol, meant to reflect Article One of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, was rejected by the ICC despite support from Cricket Australia.